‘Secret Lives of Mormon Wives’ trades Utah for California in exciting new spinoff
Premiering Nov. 12, “The Secret Wives of Mormon Wives: Orange County” trades Utah for California, following original cast member Jen Affleck as she attempts to build a new version of “MomTok” and find community after moving to Orange County. All eight episodes of the first season are available to stream on Hulu and Disney +.
The series introduces eight new women alongside Affleck: podcast host Bobbi Althoff, lifestyle content creators Aspyn Ovard and Salome Andrea, former Youtuber Madison Bontempo, former Division I tennis player McCall DaPron, former ICU nurse and podcast host Avery Woods, fitness instructor Ashleigh Pease and stay at home mother Jordan McClanahan.
The new cast is divided into two friend groups that must learn to coexist. The “Molly Mormon’s,” made up of DaPron, McClanahan, Bontempo, Pease and Affleck, are active members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints. The “Non Actives,” consisting of Ovard, Althoff, Andrea and Woods have different relationships with the faith. Their contrasting lifestyles quickly become a major source of conflict throughout the season.
DaPron takes on the self appointed role of the “Mouthpiece of the Mormon Church,” often criticizing the choices of the women who do not share her traditional views. Her disagreements with Ovard become tense after she discusses not supporting the church and revealing her polyamorous relationship. Ovard also shares her daughter’s terminal cancer diagnosis, adding a more personal storyline to the season.
Other relationships bring their own complications. Affleck navigates a rocky marriage with her husband Zac while expecting another child, and Andrea’s yearlong separation from her husband Aaron becomes a major source of drama after they both dated other people. Andrea’s relationship with Chase McWhorter, a member of the original Utah cast, resurfaces when he makes a cameo at Kyler Fisher’s birthday party.
Bontempo and her husband Fisher, also face major scrutiny. Concerns about their relationship lead the group to organize an intervention for Bontempo in the finale. Meanwhile, Woods faces criticism from McClanahan after her past OnlyFans account becomes a topic of conflict.
Althoff initially clashed with DePron, but eventually developed a friendship with her, showing that not every disagreement ends in a falling out.
The season also features cameos from Mayci Neeley and Mikayla Matthews during the group’s Las Vegas trip, connecting the spin off to its Utah roots.
The new setting does not necessarily make the franchise feel entirely new. Variety critic Alison Herman makes a similar point in her review titled “The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives’ Spinoff ‘Orange County’ Reheats Influencer Beef With Better Scenery.”
Herman argues that the conflicts and cast dynamics closely resemble those of the original series, suggesting that a change in scenery does not necessarily create a new reality television formula. That criticism reflects one of the season’s biggest weaknesses, familiar arguments about friendships, relationships and social media often take center stage.
Still, the cast’s different backgrounds and beliefs create plenty of opportunities for conflict, while developing friendships give the season moments beyond the arguments.
The finale leaves several storylines unresolved. Affleck filed for divorce right before the series premiered, while Bontempo and Fisher’s relationship remains uncertain. Woods and McClanahan also have unresolved tensions, leaving questions about whether their friendship can recover.
Hulu has not publicly announced a second season, but the cliffhangers leave plenty of material for a possible return. The spin off may follow a similar relatiy television formula, but its mix of new personalities and unfinished drama gives viewers a reason to keep watching.
